A small group of people are upset that the efforts of LeadK are making its way into many states. I think those that are afraid do not understand the core value of the initiative and find what it stands for intimidating based upon unfounded beliefs. I personally was there when the outlining of the first bill began in California. ALL school and state leaders, including Oral Schools, Deaf with special needs schools, SEE signing schools and yes the California School for the Deaf were present. All of those individuals wrote this bill together. Unbelievably to me, they all came together for one common goal. A child being ready for kindergarten and that is it! I was truly surprised to see the head of the Oral school in the same room with the representative from the Deaf school ( ASL & English ). What it showed me is there is an educational issue for children who arrive to kindergarten without the foundation they need to succeed. Whether they are Oral or signing, all educators want the same thing for these children and that is preparing them for life with a foundation of a rich language. If that mean spoken English, then that is what it means. If that means ASL and English, then that is what it means. However, parents have the right to know if their children are at risk before it is too late.
What LeadK is not… is the Deaf communities’ avenue to force hearing parents to sign with their children. Let us dispel that myth again for the umpteenth time! What LEAD-K IS…”is a goal to show accountability with the states tracking and monitoring the language acquisition process for deaf kids between the ages of 0-5. The purpose of this law is to ensure that all deaf children have the foundation of language acquisition ready for kindergarten and lifetime academic achievement. Additionally, the goal is to inform parents whether their deaf children are acquiring language through IFSP and IEP meetings. The parents have the right to know if their child is not meeting the language acquisition milestones so they can have a plan of action while the deaf child is very young.“ (Credit Julie Rems Smario ) EQUAL ACCESS… THAT IS IT!
Now, with that said. Many are also afraid because ASL and English bi-lingual Deaf people now have a well-known spokesperson, Nyle Dimarco, to raise awareness of the language deprivation occurring throughout our nation. It is an epidemic and teachers of the deaf are seeing the results of children not having early access. While technologically advanced hearing devices have made it easier for deaf children to hear English, let us face the facts, it does not work for everyone. Despite how many people like to spin it, not everyone qualifies for these advanced technological devices and sometimes they do not work. So then, the questions are as follows, what happens to those kids whose technology fails them? What happens to those whose technology does not work despite their years of efforts? What happens to those children unqualified for the advanced technology who are stuck in the middle? If those children’s assessments continue in the same way as they have been in years past then they will not be ready with a solid language foundation that is critical.
This spokesperson, Nyle Dimarco has captured the hearts of many Deaf and hearing people alike and he has become a tremendous role model for all children Deaf and hearing. Again, I think people are afraid of what Nyle’s foundation and LeadK together can do to bridge the gap and focus on what is important to the child’s well-being, love and language.
We had the privilege of being a part of the first annual fundraiser for this collaboration and seeing what it has been able to accomplish is unbelievable. We are truly excited and look forward to seeing this cause grow and flourish as it brings awareness to the language deprivation in many of our deaf children.
Now, let us be honest about where our family is, we do not hide it. We chose not to provide our child with technological advancements despite qualifying for them and many have said that we are limiting his options, narrowing his view of life, requiring him to use interpreters for his entire lifetime, limiting his family members who can communicate with him, and forcing him to struggle in this hearing world with communication. Some have gone as far to say that we are abusing our child and endangering him by not giving him every opportunity. And I would say you have a right to that opinion. It is your right to feel that way. However, there are those who feel the exact opposite. And that is their right to feel that way.
Nevertheless, for our family, and us the way of life that we have chosen works. It more than works, our Deaf child thrives in it. In addition, we do not judge families who have taken the route with technology because we understand, as we have been there ourselves. We have had all the same concerns as many. We have done the research, weighed the pros and cons, and for us it just did not feel right. We took what we call the holistic approach to life and just wanted to see what the child could do without going to doctors regularly trying to fix his problem, going to speech therapists regular trying him to get to say words that may or may not mean anything to him. We decided to let him be different yet surround him with people exactly like him to build the confidence in who is as a person. We decided to let him not feel like there is anything wrong with himself and that he’s just fine the way he is. We decided to give him the mindset that despite his Deafness he can do and be anything he wants to be. And we are so glad we made the decision we did in the way we did it because we have seen him month after month, grow just like hearing children and children with technological devices that work. He’s learning his ABC’s, counting, spelling names, being conniving as he tries to get out of timeouts, being stubborn, and overall just being your average 4 year old! When Nyle came along it was just icing on the cake! We feel every accomplishment Nyle makes in the public’s eye continues to prove to us that the decision we made and continue to make for our family is a good one. Seeing our child with Nyle himself communicating with the confidence and joy as any other Deaf child from Deaf parents again proved to us that hearing parents could do this. While our journey is not over and we have a long road ahead of us, we know that we have a foundation of love and language to build on which is what is best for our Deaf child.
Finally, we feel that every hearing parent needs to know that there is this rich amazing community of people who are just like their deaf children and they need to know that this community exists, is flourishing and has an amazing group of individuals to get to know. Once a hearing parent has had the opportunity to know a Deaf person in the Deaf community, then we feel you have a full spectrum of choices, not just, what your physicians are telling you. There is group of people just like your deaf child and they are there waiting to accept them if the time comes. Why not look at it a different way and give the Deaf community the first chance rather than the last. What is the harm? They can offer your deaf child something you cannot as a hearing parent… knowledge and understanding of what it is like to be a Deaf person.
And that is my perspective.
8 thoughts on “Afraid of LEADK and NDF.”
Well said – researched, evaluated and implemented. May God continue to bless your family as you all face life individually and together. Your son will thank you as he grows and learns how blessed he was to have your support and the support of the deaf community.
Thank you so vey much for all of your hard work and your amazing perspective! Growing up one of my best friends was a CODA. The hearing community needs more Deaf role models like you. When individuals have access to language there are no limits to what one can achieve.
Thank you again!
Kind words. But Heath is Deaf. The rest of us are hearing 😉
My HoH son is four. I wish we had families like yours nearby. I wish we had a large enough young Deaf population for playdates. We found out only a year ago that he was not hearing us clearly. That’s three years old! Language deprivation!
We’ve started to make up for lost time, and like you said in your LEAD-K video, we’ve discovered that he’s just a normal 4 year old, with normal four year old thoughts. Thoughts that he couldn’t get out before because he didn’t know the words.
One year into signing and using technology, and his language (in both languages) is soaring. “I like my hands” he declared in English. And then he told me a story about an octopus and a dolphin using those hands. He tossed in English, but honestly I wouldn’t have followed the story except for his classifiers and signs.
Even though he’s hard of hearing (not deaf, hopefully someday he’ll identify as Deaf, though), speech therapy will take years to get him to the point where his speech ability matches his language. I don’t want to wait any longer to hear his ideas about tentacles or a dolphin’s blow hole. I don’t care which language he speaks to us in, if it’s in ASL or English, I just want to hear his mind.
And as his brain stretches beyond the concrete to the abstract through imaginative play, he depends more on sign to get us to understand what he means. He can’t just point if we don’t get it.
So I wish we had more families like yours to surround us and help us help him expand his language.
But we keep moving forward with the tough work of learning a new language. And maybe some day another family will join us.
Thanks for confirming our reasons for signing. And thanks for explaining LEAD-K’S mission. From a mother of a formerly language deprived preschooler to your family of a language thriving preschooler, thanks.
I can’t imagine how hard it is to find out so late in your sons life but it sounds like he is quickly catching up and that is amazing! Keep working at it even when it feels really hard. Your efforts will pay off. I don’t know from personal experience but I have seen first hand young men who have flourished in academics and sports with hearing parents at the Deaf school. Search online hopefully there are people closer to you with children or even older role models! Take care!
LEAD-K tried to pass a bill in RI that would assess every child from 0-18 in BOTH ASL and English regardless of those primary language and if they did not meet the benchmark (which most would not if they do not use them) would have training written into their IEP. It’s not fear of LEAD-K and NFD it’s fear people are going to believe others (such as this article) when they try and say LEAD-K is from 0-5 and they will be assessed in their primary language. The ones who continuously say anyone against LEAD-K obviously do not understand the initiative are the one’s who do not understand or refuse to acknowledge what is happening in other states.
For me personally I can only comment on California, my experience and what I have seen personally. LeadK in California works and it was designed with the oral schools. I was there while they were all agreeing to the terms. The lobbyist advocated for all parties equally. I’m truly sorry that RI failed to follow the California model and RI is no longer part of LEADK. This is what I know. I’m sorry that the leaders in the Deaf community couldn’t work together with the leaders in the oral community like they did here in California. I hope that you all can work out something. However, What about the children who don’t qualify for the CIs , who the CIs don’t work for them or the hard of hearing kids who are not in the speech banana. As parents of children who are a part of the Deaf community whether oral or signing we need to worry about all the children. Not just a select few who are privileged. All children deserve our attention as a community.
I can not wait to become fluent in ASL! It’s an exciting new passion of mine infinitely!
Thank you Nyle for opening my eyes to something I never seen or knew before.